Bracket Junkie: Bubble squalor nine days out

Printable Version of Bracket »

 

Notes: Ohio State was moved from Milwaukee to Providence, and Pittsburgh was moved from Providence to Milwaukee so that Brigham Young could be placed in a pod where the Cougars would be able to avoid a Sunday game. This is the first time I’ve had to move pod assignments because of Brigham Young, and I hope it’s the last. Also, in the conference bid breakdowns, I am going to put teams I consider locks for the NCAA Tournament in bold. My definition of a lock is a team that could lose out and would still be at least 98-percent likely to get in. Right now, I have 31 teams as locks plus 22 other bids accounted for by conference champions. That leaves 12 spots still up for grabs, though Oklahoma State and Louisville are just about locked in.

 

Bracketing Challenges: Kansas slips just past Syracuse and into the top overall seed position after defeating Kansas State on Wednesday. This is very close, however, and the top overall seed will likely come down to who goes further in their conference tournaments. Kentucky could also be in the mix if it wins the SEC Tournament and neither Kansas nor Syracuse wins its conference tournament.

 

I don’t see how Duke is not still a No. 1 seed. The Blue Devils have three top-25 wins, same as Kentucky; and nine top-50 wins, four more than Kentucky. Of course, Duke has three more losses than the Wildcats, but is it possible that the difference in losses can be found in the difference between Kentucky’s 41st-ranked strength of schedule and Duke’s seventh-ranked one? Yet, Duke is on the No. 2 seed line for some people, and Kentucky is firmly ensconced as a No. 1. Interesting. The Blue Devils’ grip on a top seed is not firm, and a slip-up in the conference tournament could combine with a conference tournament championship for any of a half-dozen teams to knock Duke off the line, but right now, I don’t find a compelling argument against Duke.

 

As a whole, I really feel comfortable with the way I’ve seeded these teams. There are some tricky seedings on lines four through seven, but — with the exception of the teams I moved up or down for conference balancing, most of the seeds “feel” right. Many of you may disagree with that assessment, and feel free to voice your differences in the comments section or via e-mail. Nine days to go until Selection Sunday!

 

Moving In as At-large: Memphis, Rhode Island

 

Moving Out as At-large: Connecticut, Dayton

 

Moving In as Automatic: Jacksonville (Atlantic Sun)

 

Moving Out as Automatic: Belmont (Atlantic Sun)

 

On the Bubble: Though I like the seeding for this projection, the bubble is an absolute mess. Any of the last five in could reasonably be left out. The problem is finding the teams to replace them. Illinois has lost four of five and still can’t manage to find its way out of the field. Rhode Island dropped four of five before it vaulted back in with a comfortable home win over Charlotte. Memphis enters the field for the first time after a road win over UAB, but the Blazers maintain their spot thanks to a strong non-conference performance and an 11-4 record in the Conference USA. Saint Mary’s hasn’t played since Saturday, and that was more than good enough to stay in the field. Read More »


Bracket Junkie: Big Ten injuries likely to affect seeds

Printable Version of Bracket »

 

Bracketing Challenges: I’ll discuss the biggest challenge — finding the final at-large team — in the “On the Bubble” section below. As far as seeding challenges, the Big Ten’s penchant for major injuries is causing a lot of ambiguity. Injuries to Purdue’s Robbie Hummel, Ohio State’s Evan Turner and Michigan State’s Kalin Lucas are all likely to affect their teams’ seeding. In this projection, Purdue gets bumped down to a No. 2 seed after word that Hummel will miss the remainder of the season with a torn ACL suffered at Minnesota on Wednesday. Lucas is back now, of course, but Michigan State lost the game that Lucas was injured in, the game he missed and the game in which he came back. I think the Spartans are being given too large a benefit of the doubt, as MSU lost by 18 to Wisconsin in the game in which Lucas was injured and by 12 at home to Purdue in the game in which he returned, but they move from a No. 6 to a No. 5 because of that injury. Finally, Ohio State lost three of six when Turner was injured, but is 12-3 since his return. OSU gets a bump from a No. 5 to a No. 3. It’s educated guesswork at this point.

 

Moving In as At-large: (none)

 

Moving Out as At-large: (none)

 

Moving In as Automatic: (none)

 

Moving Out as Automatic: (none)

 

On the Bubble: This was the toughest time I’ve had this season filling out the field. Thirty-three of the 34 at-large bids were easy to find, but the last team proved elusive. My model showed only five teams with a legitimate case — Charlotte, Cincinnati, Saint Mary’s, San Diego State and Seton Hall. Charlotte and Cincy actually rated out highest, but SDSU’s strong RPI (37) and recent play put the Aztecs in. The Bearcats continue to have an underrated profile thanks to non-conference wins over Maryland and Vanderbilt. Their four wins against RPI top-50 teams — which includes a sweep of UConn — are more than any other team under consideration. With wins over Gonzaga and Kansas out of conference, Arizona squeaked in last season despite losing five of its last six, including a first-round Pac-10 Tournament loss after a 9-9 conference season. Cincinnati could be this year’s Arizona, only with a finish that’s easier for the committee to stomach. Read More »


Bracket Junkie: Four in, four out of latest projection

Printable Version of Bracket »

 

Notes: Part of the reason why there are so many changes in this projection is because I’ve switched my model weightings from in-season to end-of-season mode. In other words, I use the proportion of conference, non-conference and total games played throughout the early portion of the season to establish weights for things like conference RPI or non-conference strength of schedule. But I’m finding the full-season projections are a bit more indicative now that we’re so late in the season. The principles are the same, but there is a little more of a shakeup because of that. This is part of why Saint Mary’s drops out of the field despite winning on the road. Now that the conference weights have gone from about two-thirds to full, the Gaels’ conference numbers — which aren’t particularly good — give SMC a hit.

 

Bracketing Challenges: Two of the most difficult spots to fill in this projection were the last two spots on the No. 2 seedline. Pittsburgh, Villanova and Kansas State were the main combatants for this spot. K-State had a slight disadvantage with just six wins against top-100 teams — compared to 13 for Pittsburgh and 11 for Villanova — but all six of the Wildcats’ top-100 wins are against top-50 teams, and Frank Martin’s team has a 4-1 record against the RPI top 25, which earned K-State one of the two remaining No. 2 seeds. With a head-to-head win and two more victories against top-100 teams, Pitt got the nod over Villanova for the last one.

 

Moving In as At-large: Connecticut, Florida, Marquette, San Diego State

 

Moving Out as At-large: Charlotte, Cincinnati, Saint Mary’s, William & Mary

 

Moving In as Automatic: Jacksonville (Atlantic Sun), Wofford (Southern), Troy (Sun Belt)

 

Moving Out as Automatic: Belmont (Atlantic Sun), College of Charleston (Southern), North Texas (Sun Belt)

 

On the Bubble: The primary thing that moving from an in-season to end-of-season model did for the bubble was bump Saint Mary’s and William & Mary out and move Marquette and San Diego State in to replace those teams. William & Mary had a loss it could ill afford at Iona on Friday night. The Tribe wasn’t competitive in a 68-52 loss, which will probably be too much of an eyesore for the committee to ignore. Saint Mary’s needs to at least make the conference final, but, based on the committee’s recent handling of at-large candidates in weaker conferences, that might not be enough. Marquette got the road win it needed at Cincinnati after dropping Thursday’s home matchup with Pittsburgh. SDSU won its fourth in a row over Utah on Saturday but will face a very difficult test at Brigham Young on Wednesday.

 

Connecticut is perhaps the most controversial inclusion in the field, but as the Huskies’ record approaches .500 in conference, the quality of their schedule puts them over the top. There simply aren’t many bubble teams that can boast two top-25 wins and four top-50 wins. Illinois is the only other team ranked 25th or worse in my at-large model that can match UConn in that area. The Huskies have a very big game at home against West Virginia on Monday. Elsewhere, Cincy couldn’t afford a home loss to a team it is fighting with around the bubble, and Charlotte likewise lost at home, albeit to a very good Xavier team. On the plus side, Florida came up with a huge road win in Oxford to all but dash Mississippi’s at-large hopes.

 

I believe that the only four teams that aren’t in my projection and could legitimately be projected in a field today are the four teams that moved out this weekend. Wichita State, Seton Hall, Memphis, Arizona State and all of the other teams on the outside looking in need at least a win or two before they can be considered more than intriguing.

 

ACC: Duke continued its winning ways, pulling away from Virginia Tech late in Sunday night’s encounter at Cameron. Winners of six straight since that embarrassment in D.C., the Blue Devils are poised to grab a No. 1 should Purdue fall. The other three No. 1’s — Kansas, Syracuse, Kentucky — have created enough separation that one loss would not likely move them down a line. Maryland got a huge home win over Georgia Tech, one that puts the Yellow Jackets in mild discomfort. GaTech, Maryland, Florida State, Clemson and VaTech all have some winning to do before they can feel entirely comfortable, but the standard each must meet to maintain its bid shouldn’t require straining to achieve. Wake Forest lost its second straight on Saturday — this time against North Carolina State in Raleigh — but the Demon Deacons still rate out higher than the other five non-Duke entrants thanks to their five wins against top-50 teams. By comparison, Virginia Tech has four such wins; Clemson, Maryland, Florida State and Georgia Tech have three each.

 

ACC Bid Breakdown:

 

Duke (No. 2)
Clemson (No. 8, moved to No. 7 seed for conference balancing)
Wake Forest (No. 8)
Georgia Tech (No. 8)
Maryland (No. 9)
Virginia Tech (No. 10, 10th-to-last in)
Florida State (No. 10, ninth-to-last in)

 

Big 12: Oklahoma State tried to put to rest any doubts about its candidacy with a home win over Baylor this weekend. That was the first of four straight tough games for the Cowboys who now travel to Austin before hosting Kansas and then revisiting the Lone Star State for a matchup with Texas A&M. Texas bounces back up to a No. 3 seed at the expense of Vanderbilt. The Longhorns escaped from Lubbock with a win on Saturday. Missouri, Kansas State and Texas A&M each avoided upsets against low-tier competition. Not much to see here. The main issues are whether Oklahoma State will slip back toward the bubble and where the top teams are seeded.

 

Big 12 Bid Breakdown:

 

Kansas (No. 1)
Kansas State (No. 2)
Texas (No. 3)
Baylor (No. 5)
Texas A&M (No. 7)
Missouri (No. 7)
Oklahoma State (No. 7, moved to No. 8 seed for conference balancing)

 

Big East: Lazar Hayward’s 3-pointer in the final seconds of regulation put Marquette into overtime against Cincinnati on Sunday in a game it would eventually win. The Golden Eagles now head to the NYC Metro area for a pair of games this week, first against a St. John’s team that has damaged several bubble teams’ hopes of late and then to a Seton Hall team that will be desperate for a win. The Pirates, playing with a visibly hampered Jeremy Hazell, couldn’t complete a comeback win at West Virginia on Saturday. They have a big week of home games with Rutgers visiting followed by Marquette. Two wins could put Seton Hall close, despite many writing the Pirates off.

 

Villanova has continued to slip since entering the meat of its schedule. The Wildcats host USF before traveling to Syracuse in a game that could decide the regular-season conference champion. One potential storyline is West Virginia’s rise toward a No. 1 seed. The Mountaineers rate sixth in my seeding model after two straight wins, and they have plenty of chances to impress down the stretch — at UConn, vs. Cincy, vs. Georgetown, at Villanova. A strong finish into the Big East Tournament could allow WVU to nab a No. 1 seed should Purdue and Duke have a misstep.

 

Big East Bid Breakdown:

 

Syracuse (No. 1)
West Virginia (No. 2)
Pittsburgh (No. 2)
Villanova (No. 3)
Georgetown (No. 3)
Louisville (No. 9)
Connecticut (No. 11, moved to No. 12 seed for conference balancing; seventh-to-last in)
Marquette (No. 11, moved to No. 12 seed for conference balancing; fourth-to-last in)
Cincinnati (fourth-to-last out)
Seton Hall (sixth-to-last out)
South Florida (ninth-to-last out)

 

Big Ten: Someone needs to explain Michigan State’s continued high seeding to me. I still saw some No. 3 seeds out there entering this weekend, and I expect some No. 4’s even after Sunday’s home loss to Ohio State, but the only reason why is the name on the front of the jersey. The Spartans have exactly two wins against top-50 opponents this season — Gonzaga and Wisconsin, both at home. MSU has now lost four straight against teams with winning records.

 

Purdue pulled out a win at home against Illinois to maintain its hold on a No. 1 seed. The Illini, despite playing so well of late, remain at tremendous risk of losing their spot in the field. They now visit a Michigan team, which seems to alternate no-shows with great efforts, before finishing with Minnesota at home, at Ohio State and Wisconsin at home. That is not a comfortable finish for a team on the bubble. Elsewhere near the bubble, Minnesota continues to hang around despite that devastating week when the Gophers lost to Michigan at home and then at Northwestern in overtime. A home win over Purdue on Wednesday is just what Tubby Smith’s team needs to get the Gophers back in the mix.

 

Wisconsin nearly blew a 14-point lead at home to Northwestern but held on for the win on Sunday. Still finding his way after missing six weeks with a broken hand, Jon Leuer looked better, though still not 100 percent. Their record and seed may suffer as Leuer works back into game shape, but Bo Ryan’s team will be very dangerous once that happens. Ohio State continues to play like one of the best teams in the country. The Buckeyes’ don’t have the resume to match warrant a top-two seed, but, after factoring in Evan Turner’s injury and OSU’s splendid play of late, a No. 2 seed is still a possibility with a strong finish.

 

Big Ten Bid Breakdown:

 

Purdue (No. 1)
Wisconsin (No. 4)
Ohio State (No. 4)
Michigan State (No. 6)
Illinois (No. 12, third-to-last in)
Minnesota (13th-to-last out)

 

Pac-10: Finally a weekend when the teams the Pac-10 needed to win did so. Cal recovered from that quizzical performance in Corvallis on Thursday with a 15-point win at Oregon on Saturday. Washington never let UCLA think it was in the game in Seattle on Saturday night, winning by 29. Arizona State had the biggest win of the three, traveling to Tucson and avenging a January home loss to Arizona with a 73-69 victory. This sets up a crucial trip to NorCal for ASU, which ends with a visit to Berkeley on Saturday. A sweep of that trip — as unlikely as that might be — would put the Sun Devils right in the mix for an at-large bid. Washington travels to Washington State on Saturday to start a three-game road swing that will end the regular season. The bad news is where the games are, as the Huskies have struggled away from home this season. The good news is that the three games — which include a season-ending trip to the Oregons — are against the squads likely to finish 8-9-10 in the Pac-10. I’m not sure anything worse than a sweep would put UW in a good place entering the Pac-10 Tournament.

 

Pac-10 Bid Breakdown:

 

California (No. 9)
Arizona State (eighth-to-last out)
Washington (10th-to-last out)

 

SEC: Vanderbilt couldn’t hit the broad side of a barn door on Saturday but still nearly defeated Kentucky in Nashville. That loss drops the Commodores to the No. 4 seedline, but a 3-1 finish would keep Kevin Stallings in the field’s top quarter. Tennessee is on the edge of a top-four seed after a win at South Carolina on Saturday. Temple’s seven top-50 wins to Tennessee’s one gave the Owls the edge for that last No. 4 seed despite the Vols having the better marks in most other areas. At the bubble, Florida’s win at Mississippi was a major step to getting Billy Donovan’s team into its first NCAA Tournament since 2007. The Gators do have a very difficult schedule remaining with home games against Vanderbilt and Tennessee and road matchups at Georgia and Kentucky. A split of those four games would likely keep Florida on the plus side of the bubble. I’m not sure Mississippi State or Mississippi deserves much further mention, although both teams feature the sort of remaining schedule that could allow either to put together a winning streak that would get them back into serious consideration.

 

SEC Bid Breakdown:

 

Kentucky (No. 1)
Vanderbilt (No. 4)
Tennessee (No. 5)
Florida (No. 11, fifth-to-last in)
Mississippi State (15th-to-last out)
Mississippi (20th-to-last out)

 

Mid-Majors: The Colonial Athletic Association has to wish that Bracket Busters didn’t exist. William & Mary, Northeastern and Old Dominion all suffered losses that hurt both themselves and the league. Virginia Commonwealth was one of the three CAA teams to actually win its Bracket Buster game, but the Rams’ 10-6 conference record now looks unacceptable after the performances of conference mates this weekend. VCU does finish the regular season at Old Dominion, a game that figures to hurt ODU more than it would help VCU should the latter win.

 

UNI’s win over Old Dominion probably means that the Panthers will be dancing regardless of what happens in the Valley Tournament. Siena’s loss at Butler probably means the opposite. The Saints are pseudo-host of the MAAC Tournament in Albany, and they better win it if they expect to be in the NCAAs for the third year in a row. Utah State’s win over Wichita State means that the Aggies will have a real case should they lose in the WAC Tournament. In the Conference USA, UAB, UTEP and Memphis could all enter the C-USA Tourney on the precipice of at-large bids.

 

Then there’s the Atlantic 10. There are enough A-10 teams under consideration — seven — that the league probably deserves its own entry. Richmond, Temple and Xavier all look like near locks at this point. Rhode Island is the fourth A-10 team for now. The Rams drubbed lowly Fordham on Saturday, but they face a real opponent in St. Bonaventure in Olean on Saturday. URI has lost to three straight non-Fordham opponents. Dayton’s loss at Duquesne was not the result Brian Gregory’s team needed to solidify its bid. The Flyers still have trips to Temple and Richmond as well as a home game against Saint Louis upcoming. They’ll need a 3-1 finish to feel safe. Charlotte lost by 14 at home to Xavier to drop its third straight and fall out of the field. The 49ers host St. Joseph’s and travel to George Washington this week before the real tests in the regular season’s final week. Of course, every game is a test for Charlotte right now. Finally, after a sixth straight win this weekend, Saint Louis has moved into the last dozen teams out. With games remaining against Xavier, Dayton and Temple, the Billikens could makes things interesting with a 3-1 finish of their own.

 

Mid-Majors Bid Breakdown:

 

New Mexico (No. 3)
Temple (No. 4)
Xavier (No. 5)
Butler (No. 5)
Brigham Young (No. 6)
Northern Iowa (No. 6)
Gonzaga (No. 6)
Richmond (No. 7)
Utah State (No. 8)
UNLV (No. 9)
UAB (No. 10, eighth-to-last in)
Old Dominion (No. 10)
Rhode Island (No. 11, sixth-to-last in)
UTEP (No. 12, moved to No. 11 for conference balancing)
Siena (No. 12, moved to No. 11 for conference balancing)
Dayton (No. 12, second-to-last in)
San Diego State (No. 13, last in)
Charlotte (last out)
William & Mary (second-to-last out)
Saint Mary’s (third-to-last out)
Wichita State (fifth-to-last out)
Memphis (seventh-to-last out)
Northeastern (11th-to-last out)
Saint Louis (12th-to-last out)
Virginia Commonwealth (14th-to-last out)
Marshall (16th-to-last out)
Louisiana Tech (17th-to-last out)
New Mexico State (18th-to-last out)
Tulsa (19th-to-last out)


Bracket Junkie: Plenty of posturing, no changes in at-large field

Printable Version of Bracket »

 

Bracketing Challenges: There were a couple of challenges I want to make note of, the first coming at the end of the No. 3 seedline. The battle here was between Vanderbilt and Baylor, who have very similar profiles. Both teams are 19-5 and have two wins against the RPI top 25. I went with the Commodores primarily because their two top-25 wins come in just three chances. Also, their conference RPI is 3. Only Kansas (1) and Duke (2) are ranked higher for play within the conference.

 

The other thing I wanted to address is Wake Forest. After the Demon Deacons’ loss to Virginia Tech in Blacksburg, I dropped them from a No. 5 to a No. 7, which is quite harsh. Wake ranks 23rd in my BTI seed model, which should equate to a No. 6 seed. However, Butler and Ohio State rate out on the No. 7 seedline, and I feel like both would surely be higher than that right now. So, I bumped the Bears and Buckeyes to No. 6’s at the expense of Richmond and Wake Forest. One could argue that Xavier — which is ranked 21st in the model — should have been the one to get bumped down, and I wouldn’t put up too much resistance in my rebuttal. I just didn’t go in that direction. Read More »


Bracket Junkie: Plenty of bubble movement

Printable Version of Bracket »

 

Note: Vanderbilt and Illinois played in the regular season. The Selection Committee tries to avoid regular-season and recent NCAA Tournament matchups in the first two rounds, but it was impossible to find Illinois another spot on the No. 12 seedline, so we’re keeping the bracket the way it is.

 

Bracketing Challenges: There was a lot of potential movement among the top five seedlines. With teams like Baylor and Pittsburgh picking up big wins while West Virginia and Georgetown dropping tough games, a bunch of teams met around the third seedline. New Mexico actually rated out as a No. 2 seed, but it’s hard to imagine such a low-profile mid-major being seeded so high, despite seven wins against top-50 teams. Read More »


Writing nice things about two Pac-10 teams

After two years in which the best Pac-10 players were also the best players in the nation, everyone knows the struggles the league has suffered this season. There’s no reason to post the litany of embarrassments the Pac-10 has suffered this season, as the conference has become a national punchline. Lost, though, in all of the giggles and putdowns are the California Bears.

 

Mike Montgomery’s team completed a home sweep of the Washington schools with a 16-point win over Washington State on Saturday. Two nights earlier, the Bears were even more impressive, never allowing UW in the game in a 12-point victory featured on ESPN’s “Duke plays UNC for the first time” Week. That win avenged a 15-point loss in Seattle, a Jan. 16 game that wasn’t even that close.

 

Now 9-4 in conference and 17-8 overall, the Bears are on their way to a Pac-10 regular-season title and a 20-win season despite playing one of the dozen toughest schedules in the nation. Cal’s problem in getting into the NCAA Tournament is partly its own fault. The Bears have yet to beat a likely NCAA Tournament team, going 0-4 against Syracuse, Ohio State, New Mexico and Kansas outside of conference. And, since the Pac-10 is down this season, Cal’s nine wins against eight different league members may fail to sway the Selection Committee. Read More »


Bracket Junkie: Big 12 is back to Big Eight

Printable Version of Bracket »

 

Bracketing Challenges: This bracket came together well, but there were still a few challenges. Most notably, any of the last three teams in the field could easily be omitted. South Carolina, Texas Tech and VCU have thin cases, but I found them marginally more compelling than Mississippi, Florida, Cincinnati, Virginia Tech and Louisville. If the bracket were announced today, I would not be very confident in those final three teams.

 

The other challenge continues to be in filling out the top four seedlines. Finding the last two No. 3 seeds was particularly difficult with the poor play of Texas and after Wisconsin’s home defeat to Illinois. Still, the full-season profiles of those two teams remains stronger than Vanderbilt, Gonzaga and the others on the No. 4 seedline. Read More »


Bracket Junkie: An unholy mess

Printable Version of Bracket »

 

Bracketing Challenges: Well, it finally happened. After relatively smooth bracketing so far this season, I ran into a bunch of problems trying to separate teams from the same conference. The Big East and ACC grouped teams in the 2-3-6-7-10-11 seeds; the Big 12 grouped in the 1-4-5-8-9 seeds. Therefore, I had to move a record five teams up and five teams down by one seedline. We don’t know how common this is for the NCAA Tournament committee because it doesn’t reveal this information like I do, but I would guess it happens with 2-4 teams per year. I’m hopeful that these uneven distributions work themselves out by mid-March.

 

It’s important to note that Cincinnati was moved from its true seedline of No. 10 because three of the spots where the Bearcats could have played already had a Big East team in the eight-team pod. In the other spot, the No. 7 seed was Xavier, a team that Cincinnati plays every year. The NCAA prefers to avoid those rematches early in the tournament, and that’s especially the case since UC-XU is a notorious rivalry.

 

Breakdown: One of the surprising parts of this bracket to many of you might be Michigan State’s position as a No. 3 seed after its loss to Wisconsin. MSU was being propped up by that undefeated conference record, and now that it’s no longer, we can evaluate the Spartans on their paltry list of quality victories. Michigan State has just two wins against top-50 RPI teams — Gonzaga and Wisconsin at home, and Sparty has yet to play Ohio State or Purdue. The Boilermakers are now a No. 2 seed even though they’ve actually played an easier conference schedule than MSU so far, but they have four top-50 wins, including Tennessee and West Virginia out of conference. Read More »